Making a Move

November 8, 2007

During the organization meetings at the end of last month, the Phillies targeted pitching as their primary goal for the off-season, a point which isn’t new to anyone.

As has been mentioned previously, the free agent starting pitching market is as thin as a razor blade. Signing a free agent pitcher for multiple years at major bucks can hurt as much as a cut from a razor blade. 

Getting a quality closer would allow the Phillies to move Brett Myers back to the rotation.  Various options were discussed, including free agents.

The focus then shifted to trading for a closer and Brad Lidge’s name came up.  Scouts who had seen him during the second half said he was really tough, a biting slider and a plus fast ball.  His numbers are awesome: 88 strikeouts in 67 innings (54 hits) and a 2.89 ERA over his last 53 outings.

We began discussions with Houston as the Astros have some bullpen depth and when Lidge’s name came up yesterday, things began to heat up.  The PR department first got wind late yesterday afternoon that a deal was warming up.  With medical records to review and the need to contact the players involved, the deal was announced around 10:30 last night.

Early in the season when Tom Gordon went down with an injury, the Phillies felt they had to get creative to fill his vital spot.  That’s when the decision was made to move Brett to the pen.  The decision was viewed as “panic”, “desperation” by many but in the end, it was the best move for the ball club.

With the bleak free agent market, we again became creative to improve the staff.  Lidge is quality and Brett is better than any starter on the market. 

Eric Bruntlett’s versatility fills Abraham Nunez’ role.  Eric’s ability to play shortstop is appealing because Jimmy Rollins played every game last season.  A rest now and then would be beneficial to Jimmy.

The message board has mixed reviews, which is fine.  Some are concerned that we gave up the future for winning now.  Well, the goal of this organization is to win a world championship.  I know the fans feel that way, too.  Remember, to get quality, you have to give up something. 

Adding another bullpen piece and another starter is still on the shopping list.  Getting another outfielder has entered the picture, especially if Aaron Rowand signs elsewhere.

Not wanting to wait until the winter meetings next month to improve the club, we were proactive yesterday, pulling off the first major deal of the off-season.


The Phillies made a great move here. Without breaking the bank, they added to both the back end of the bullpen and the starting rotation. Let’s hope now they concentrate on a third baseman and retaining Aaron Rowand!

Good move. I like Lidge as closer and sending Myers back to the starting rotation. Hope he keeps his head screwed on the first time he gets hit around a little and the glory of the closer role is no longer there.
SIGN Aaron, Gold glove CF, 300 avg, W.S. exp, runs into walls for you!! SIGN him!!!

Good job signing Lidge and picking up Bruntlett who is a proven utility man! Bourn wasn’t a tremendous loss, but I have to say that I’m not getting much sleep knowing that Aaron is still unsigned. PLEASE pay the money! Third base isn’t a concern – Dobbs and Helms are fine fits. Maybe we can keep Nunez if the money is right too. Where is the organization’s stance on reacquiring Lohse? He would solidify our rotation along with Hamels, Kendrick, Moyer and Eaton. Myers can be kept in the bullpen to make both sides happy and at least we’d have a proven starter if need be. I don’t get paid the big bucks to make any of these decisions, but I do know that Aaron needs to be in the forefront of all minds that matter! Thanks for letting us share!

The phillies have brought up from the farm system 2 solid starters in Hamels and Kendrick. Isn’t it about time we bring up Corasco and see if he is the real deal like so many scouts say he is?

So far I like the move to improve the pitching with the trade for Lidge. The Phillies need to get over their salary budget and go after Lohse AND Rowand. They can make up the additional salary next year when they aren’t paying Burrell. The team chemistry will take a hit if they do not sign Rowand.

Leave a Reply to Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: